← Back to portfolio

House Envy: Coming Soon to a Neighborhood Near You

By Lynn Armitage

Envy –- it’s not a pretty word. A cousin to jealousy and akin to greed, envy is born from the ugly side of human nature. One of the seven deadly sins. An emotion most honest, self-respecting people would never admit to having.

In the movie, “When Harry Met Sally,” there’s a memorable scene that says it all. While Sally is having, (how can we say this delicately?) a “love affair” with her lunch, a woman, gaping enviously from the next table, shouts, “I’ll have what she’s having!”

So why is it that the grass is always greener, the lunch always tastier, on the other side? What is it about envy that drives so many of us to despair and a good majority of us to the mall?

“From envy are born hatred, detraction, slander, joy caused by the misfortune of a neighbor and displeasure caused by his prosperity.” – St. Gregory the Great

But as nasty and ill-tempered as envy is, this little green-eyed monster has gotten a lot of press through the ages, and not just from brooding saints, either. It’s also inspired apostles and kings, poets and authors, advertisers and filmmakers. Heck, even God had something to say about it in His final commandment, “Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s house.”

Which, thank God, brings me to the perfect segue and nub of this story: Do we make improvements to our homes based on necessity or envy -- our inadvertent compulsion to “keep up with the Joneses?” And can house envy be a good thing and actually redeem itself if it drives up property values in a neighborhood?

Elizabeth Loftus, a world-renowned psychologist and distinguished professor at UC Irvine, says, “People find reference groups to compare themselves to, then judge their own success or happiness according to the group they find.” Loftus adds, “It’s puzzling why neighbors do this when they have so many other reference groups to measure up to.”

Howard Bloom, a mass behavior expert and author of “Global Brain,” has some well-published theories on envy. He says we want others to accept us, so we ape each other, “. . . get the right lawn, right paint job, most impressive Christmas ornaments. Once in good standing, we hunger for admiration and attention, to fit in and stand out simultaneously.”

I’m neither a psychological expert nor named Jones. All I know is that the home repairs I made recently didn’t come from envy, but rather, a nesting instinct.

HOW I SPENT MY SUMMER VACATION

After my divorce last year, I moved into a 39-year-old house and became a home improvement machine.

I painted, scraped ceilings, re-textured walls, installed recessed lighting and ceiling fans, refinished natural wood floors, replaced windows, doors and casings, and even transformed an old woodshed in the back yard into a bright, pink playhouse for my kids, surely an eyesore to the neighbors behind us.

I spent the entire summer bossing around men in leather tool belts. I was obsessed with re-nesting, making a new home and new life for me and my two young daughters. Apparently, divorce is good for the home improvement business, as well as the life improvement business.

Neighbors would drive or walk by, necks craned, gawking, curious to see beyond all the sandblasting. After the dust settled, I noticed a few neighbors on the street were getting new windows, too. Hmmm. It got me thinking, “Did I cause this chain reaction of home upgrades? And if so, is my street simply a microcosm of the competitive dynamics in every neighborhood, U.S.A.?”

PATIENCE, MY DEAR

“To wish to be the person you aren’t is to waste the person you are.” – John Wesley

If you asked my neighbors, Kathy and Joe MacDonald, what motivates them to upgrade the first home they ever bought four years ago, it’s not envy, but strategy.

“When we moved in, this house had original 1964 stuff. So we wrote a plan,” says 32-year-old Kathy, a part-time second-grade teacher and mother of 18-month-old Lexi. “We categorized the worst eyesore down to the least and planned strategically what to fix every summer. Next year, it’s the kitchen.”

For Joe, a 40-year-old high school teacher and baseball coach who previously lived in an apartment, it’s about pride of ownership. “I’m just happy to have a house. Upgrading doesn’t matter as much to me.” But he does admit, “the more we do, the more excited I get about it.”

Although the MacDonalds adhere to a carefully crafted remodeling plan that will turn their home into their castle in three years, Kathy wishes they’d step up the pace. Turns out, she has “new-house” envy.

“I really envy my sister’s brand new house because I hate waiting and spending so much money to update,” she says faking a pout. “I’d love to move into a new place and do nothing but decorate.”

While Kathy and Joe don’t follow neighborhood trends, they might be setting them. A few weeks after they installed a new front door, their next-door neighbors followed suit. Question is, were the Lewis’s trying to keep up with the MacDonalds?

I jumped over the hedge to find out.

KNOCK, KNOCK!

It’s a magnificent front door: stately, natural oak, inlaid with full-length, decorative, yet obscure glass that tempts even the most discreet visitor to peek inside. But whose idea was it, anyway?

Homeowners, Kim and Scott Lewis, say it was in their plans all along. “I told the realtor the front door was hideous and would be the first thing we changed,” says 42-year-old Scott, an aerospace engineer. That was four years ago. So why get a new one now?

“After years of watching neighbors get doors, it really motivated us because ours looked even worse,” confesses Kim, 43, an elementary school librarian.

Coincidental that it was installed right after the MacDonald’s?

“We just came to the same conclusion at the same time.” Individuality is important to Scott, who grew up in a tract home. “We originally planned to get the door they picked. Another neighbor down the street has it, too. But we wanted ours to look different, so we spent extra money for something unique.”

While Kim loves her one-of-a-kind door, what she secretly pines for is a lushly landscaped back yard with a built-in barbecue -- an impressive rendezvous for entertaining. Much like her cousin’s in Fresno, says Kim, turning a little green. “I used to come back from her house so depressed. Their back yard is so beautiful. But then I realized they have to live in FRESNO to have it.”

Much too high a price, if you ask me.

WINDOWS OF OPPORTUNITY

In most service industries, envy is a welcome emotion, a social behavior that stimulates the economy and fattens the bottom line. House envy, in fact, has caused money to fly into the window business.

“At least 40% of our business is referrals,” says Mike Sorochman, President of Elegant Openings, a Fountain Valley-based company that installs high-quality wood, vinyl and aluminum windows and doors. “Neighbors see the difference our windows make on another home, then call us. We don’t really advertise because word spreads so easily.”

Recently, it spread like wildfire in Garden Grove, where Elegant Openings installed new, white vinyl windows in eight different houses on the same street. The perfect chain reaction: All neighbors, all friends, who had to have what the other was having.

New windows indisputably add value to a home. How much? According to a survey by Remodeling Magazine, West Coast homeowners recoup about 73% of the cost of replacing windows. The national average is 69% (www.remodelingonline.com).

So if envy boosts the economy, should it be encouraged?

In her book, “Keeping Up With The Joneses,” Susan Matt claims there’s been a shift in social attitudes toward envy in the last century. Once considered “a destructive emotion and a sin” by nineteenth-century moralists, envy now drives the American economy. “Americans today have great faith that they can give themselves makeovers – turn themselves into who they want to be if only they have access to the right clothes, accessories and cars.”

Not to mention -- windows.

THOSE NOSEY NEIGHBORS

“Envy is a pain of mind that successful men cause their neighbors.” -- Onasander

Nothing lures people with house envy like an open house; a siren song that's music to their ears. What better way to indulge envy than to leisurely walk through someone else's home, invited and unobserved, quietly scrutinizing and comparing your upgrades to theirs, and stealing ideas at the same time? 

For realtor Donna Horn, one of the top producers at STAR Real Estate last year with over $40 million in sales, house envy is currency. “In the early stages of an open house, usually 35-40% of traffic is neighbors. That’s why some homeowners are reluctant to do them. They know a lot of neighbors will be looking at their things and aren’t serious buyers.” However, Horn says most agents see this as a marketing advantage. “These neighbors could tell friends who buy it, or after seeing the list price, be interested in selling, too.”

Since real estate agents tour homes for a living, do they ever get bitten by envy?

“Absolutely!” says Horn. “Even as a realtor, I’ll preview homes and be very disappointed with my own. Usually I’ll see something really creative I wish I had thought about.”

GODZILLA STRIKES

“Envy eats nothing but its own heart.” – German Proverb

Sometimes the little green-eyed monster turns gargantuan.

Here’s what happens when house envy gets out of control. (True story, however names were changed at the homeowners’ request.)

Last year, the Hatfields, somewhere in Southern California, decided to fulfill their lifelong dream of building a swimming pool. When the McCoys next door got wind of their plans, they immediately hired a demolition crew to tear up the back yard they had just spent thousands of dollars landscaping. Seems the McCoys wanted to be the first in the neighborhood to get a pool, at any cost. Including dignity.

“My neighbor snooped in my trash can at night to see which pool company I used,” said Hatfield. “At first, I didn’t care. But when she started telling everyone she did this and that before we did, it really bothered me.”

Needless to say, the Hatfields and McCoys now have dueling swimming pools. But what I want to know is . . . who has the more enviable tan?

DEATH, TAXES, AND ENVY

One thing is certain: Envy is pervasive. It’s part of the human condition, and knocks on everyone’s door, no matter who installed the door first.

For more than 20 years, Elizabeth Loftus, considered one of the 100 most eminent psychologists of the 20th century, lived in a 4200 sq. ft. home overlooking Lake Washington. Now she lives in a 1,300 sq. ft. condo, UCI’s faculty housing.

“Wait a minute…I have house envy!” she blurts out, reclining on my proverbial couch. Loftus recently fell in love with a 1.7 million home for sale that boasted a sweeping view of the ocean. Boy, was she envious! “As a psychologist, I should be able to figure out how not to feel this way, but I haven’t yet.”

Loftus, who lives an enviable life herself surrounded by all the privileges reserved for the cream of the academic world, attempts rational thought, “I have a very rich life, I make scientific discoveries and get to teach smart people. Why should it matter so much where I live?”

Only Loftus can answer that. But will the woman who’s been compared to Freud ever resolve her feelings of house envy?

“I’m either going to learn to love where I am,” the psychologist says with conviction, then adds, with a hint of green in her brown eyes, “Or I’m going to see if that house in Corona del Mar is still available!”



Subscribe to get sent a digest of new articles by Lynn Armitage

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.